🚩 Flag State vs. Port State: Who’s Really in Charge of Your Vessel?

My name is Davide Ramponi, I’m 21 years old and currently training as a shipping agent in Hamburg. On my blog, I take you with me on my journey into the exciting world of shipping. I share my knowledge, my experiences, and my progress on the way to becoming an expert in the field of Sale and Purchase – the trade with ships.

When it comes to maritime governance, one question has caused more than its fair share of confusion, debate—and occasionally, jurisdictional headaches:Who’s really in charge of a vessel—the flag state or the port state? ⚖️

At first glance, the answer seems simple. The flag state registers the vessel, so it should govern everything, right? Not quite. The truth is, authority at sea is split, and this division can have serious implications for shipowners, operators, and crews.

🔍 In this post, I’ll walk you through:

• 🏛️ Responsibilities of flag states

• ⚓ Port state control under international law

• ⚔️ Real-world jurisdictional conflicts

• 📋 Shipowner strategies for dual compliance

• 🔎 Enforcement trends & notable examples

Let’s set sail. ⛵

🇺🇳 Understanding Flag States: Sovereignty at Sea

Flag states are more than just an administrative detail on a ship’s stern—they are the legal foundation of a vessel’s existence. When a ship is registered under a flag, it effectively adopts the laws, regulations, and oversight of that country, regardless of where it physically sails.

✅ What Does the Flag State Control?

• 📜 Maritime Law Application: Legal standards on safety, construction, pollution, crewing.

• 🎓 Crew Certification: STCW compliance and training enforcement.

• 🔍 Surveys and Inspections: Coordination with class societies and regulatory checks.

• 🌊 High Seas Jurisdiction: Authority outside territorial waters on legal and safety matters.

⚓ Example: A Liberian-flagged container ship involved in a pollution incident in international waters will be investigated by Liberian authorities—even if the shipowner resides in Greece and the ship was en route to Singapore.

⚠️ Flag State Quality Matters

Not all flags are equal. Paris and Tokyo MoUs grade flags based on performance:

• ✅ White list: High compliance

• ⚠️ Grey list: Increased inspection likelihood

• ❌ Black list: Frequent detentions and commercial risk

🛃 Port State Control: Gatekeepers of National Waters

While flag states rule the ship in theory, port states have practical power the moment a ship enters their territorial waters. Thanks to UNCLOS and IMO conventions, port authorities can board, inspect, and even detain vessels for violations.

⚓ What Port States Can Do:

• 🧾 Inspect ships for SOLAS, MARPOL, MLC, and ISM compliance

• 🛑 Detain non-compliant ships

• 💰 Impose fines or sanctions

• 📨 Report deficiencies to flag states and industry databases

📍 Example: In 2022, the Port of Rotterdam detained a vessel for excessive sulphur content in its fuel oil. Although the ship was flagged under a compliant country, local authority enforced EU environmental standards.

🌐 Global PSC Regimes

Port State Control is organized regionally:

• 🇪🇺 Paris MoU (Europe & North Atlantic)

• 🇯🇵 Tokyo MoU (Asia-Pacific)

• 🇺🇸 USCG (United States)

• 🌍 Other MoUs in Africa, Caribbean, and Middle East

Each operates on a risk profile, but they share one mission: safer, cleaner shipping.

⚔️ When Jurisdictions Clash: Who Gets the Final Word?

What happens when the flag state says one thing and the port state says another?

This is where things get legally tricky—and commercially risky.

⚠️ Conflict Scenarios:

• 🤔 Labor Law Conflicts: MLC-compliant crews may still be challenged by stricter port labor laws.

• 💨 Pollution Disputes: Vessels compliant with MARPOL may violate local air emission limits.

• 🧳 Crew Welfare & Repatriation: Port states may intervene when flag states fail to act.

🧩 How Conflicts Are Resolved

• 📞 Bilateral diplomacy

• 📜 IMO arbitration channels

• ⚖️ Domestic courts (when detentions cause trade loss or disputes)

⚖️ Case Insight: A Panama-flagged bulker was detained in Australia over underpaid crew. Panama objected, but Australia’s PSC acted based on ILO and national labor standards. The dispute reached foreign ministries before a resolution.

🧠 Strategies for Shipowners: Dual Compliance = Smart Compliance

Shipowners are on the front line. To avoid detentions, fines, and commercial risk, they must plan for dual compliance:

🧭 1. Choose the Right Flag

Pick a flag that:

• 🟢 Appears on MoU white lists

• 🛡️ Supports vessels during disputes

• 📈 Enhances chartering appeal

💡 Tip: Cheap isn’t always smart. Factor in inspection frequency, administrative efficiency, and support services.

📍 2. Know Your Port Profiles

• 🇪🇺 EU ports → Expect strict sulphur and carbon limits

• 🇺🇸 US ports → MARPOL Annex VI and cybersecurity

• 🇦🇺 Australia/Asia → Strict safety documentation and drills

📂 3. Prepare Before Arrival

• ✅ Run internal mock PSC checks

• 📋 Update all documentation regularly

• 👨‍✈️ Train crew on local rules and port protocols

👥 4. Build a Compliance Team

• 🕵️ Hire consultants for performance audits

• 📊 Monitor inspection histories

• 🔍 Act quickly when notices arise

💻 5. Use Digital Tools

Leverage platforms like:

• DNV Veracity

• RightShip

• ABS My Digital Fleetfor inspection tracking, KPI monitoring, and emissions reporting

📈 Trends & Shifts: PSC is Getting Smarter—and Stricter

We’re entering an age of real-time compliance.

🚀 What’s Changing?

• 🛰️ Remote Inspections: Digital inspections trialed during COVID are going permanent

• 🌫️ Sensor-Based Monitoring: Emissions tracked via satellites and port-based sniffers

• 📤 Shared PSC Databases: MoUs now share inspection results to flag frequent offenders

📊 Statistic: In 2023, 6 out of 10 detentions under the Paris MoU were due to ISM and crew-related issues—not hull damage or equipment.

🧾 Conclusion: Two Authorities, One Ultimate Responsibility

⚖️ Flag state or port state—who’s in charge?Both. And neither. Because at the end of the day, responsibility rests with you—the shipowner, the operator, the manager.

Key Takeaways 🎯

• 🏛️ Flag states govern legal compliance—especially on the high seas

• 🛃 Port states enforce practical rules—especially in their harbors

• ⚔️ Conflicts happen—but can be managed with preparation

• 🧠 Dual compliance isn’t optional—it’s a strategic imperative

👇 How do you handle compliance across jurisdictions? Have you experienced PSC surprises or conflicts with flag states?

💬 Share your thoughts in the comments — I look forward to the exchange!

---

---